Lobster Rolls Recipe - An Atlantic Canadian Favorite! (2024)

As an East Coast Canadian originally from New Brunswick, there's no way I can have a blog and NOT post about seafood. I mean, that would be just insane right? lol

Practically anything and everything from the briny deeps of the sea is a favorite in this house, but the king that takes the crown is definitely fresh Atlantic lobster!

One of the best ways to enjoy those tasty morsels of succulent lobster meat is to serve it as the classic lobster roll. YUM YUM!

These amazing sandwiches areoverflowing with juicy chunks of lobster, some mayo, melted butter, a little lemon juice, lemon zest, celery, sliced green onions, and some salt and pepper. So simple but sooooo good!

If you leave some lobster claw meat intact, just tuck them in your sandwich like in the pictures – this is optional but awesome for presentation!

Serving these sandwiches with a big ol' hunk of claw meat is enough to impress just about anyone… OMG… drool…

My goodness, I wish I could have lobster every day! Don't you?

While lobster meat can cost a pretty penny depending on the season, if you look carefully in your grocery store flyers youmight be able to find some for a more reasonable cost. If you're lucky enough to live near the water, you might even want to check out the local waterfront or farmers market to find a good price.

Well, wherever you get your lobster from, you're going to LOVE it in this recipe!

Lobster rolls are very popular in the New England area of the US and also in the Atlantic Canadian provinces. Seriously, if you haven't had a lobster roll yet, please… PLEASE… do something special for yourself and make one!

You know deserve a nice treat like this once in a while! 🙂

What are the two types of lobster rolls?
Are traditional lobster rolls made with butter or mayo?

The great debate of Atlantic Canadian/New England lobster rolls versus Connecticut style lobster rolls has been raging on for years! This regional showdown has been a constant source of contention among seafood lovers.

To me, the best lobster roll recipe is the Atlantic Canadian/New England style I grew up with. The main difference between the two is that traditional Atlantic Canadian (or Maine style) lobster rolls are more like “a lobster salad”. It's served cold and dressed with mayonnaise, chopped celery, chopped green onions and other ingredients.

Connecticut style lobster rolls are served warm and doused in melted butter only, no mayonnaise or other sauces.

Both styles of lobster rolls use buttered toasted hot dog buns.

The Atlantic/Maine style cold lobster and mayonnaise combination is usually what one thinks of when they think “traditional” lobster roll.

The recipe included in this post is for the traditional Atlantic Canadian/New England style lobster roll.

Where Do Lobster Rolls Originate From?

The origins of the lobster roll are a bit mysterious, with some claiming it originated in Maine and others claiming it originated on Long Island. What we do know for certain is that the lobster roll made its first commercial appearance in Connecticut’s Milford Beach in 1929 and its popularity spread across Connecticut but not far beyond.

It wasn't until the early 1970's when lobster rolls inside of hot dog buns began being sold in Maine, New England, that they became more than locally popular, becoming a staple in the Maritime provinces of Atlantic Canada and all across North America, even being seasonally offered in McDonald's in some locations!

What Ingredients are used to make Lobster Rolls

Chilled and roughly chopped lobster meat is the star of the show. A simple mayonnaise dressing including a little melted butter, lemon juice, and lemon zest flavor the lobster meat.

A finely chopped celery stalk provides crunch and texture. Green onions as well as a pinch of salt and pepper are used.

How to make Lobster Rolls – Overview

You can find the full recipe details, including ingredient amounts and the full instructions in the recipe card at the bottom of this post, but first, here's a quick overview of how to make homemade lobster rolls!

Start by combining the chopped cooked lobster meat with the mayonnaise, melted butter, lemon juice, lemon zest, celery, green onion, salt and pepper. Chill the lobster and mayonnaise mixture in the fridge for about 10 minutes to allow the flavors to develop.

How To assemble Lobster Rolls:

Toast the buns and butter them if desired. Top cut hot dog buns are great toasted and buttered for lobster rolls! Spoon some of the lobster mixture filling into the buns. Serve immediately and enjoy!

What is the best bun for lobster roll?

In my opinion, the best lobster rolls are made with top cut New England style buns that have been carefully buttered and toasted to a perfect golden brown. The combination of crispy warm bread and succulent lobster is simply amazing!

Whichever style of lobster roll you choose to make, the bun should be a soft, split top hot dog bun. These are the traditional American, split down the middle, split top hot dog buns. These are also often called New England style hot dog buns.

The outside of the bun is slathered with butter and toasted in order to crisp it up and to give some contrast between the soft lobster and the crispy, buttery bun.

While top cut hot dog buns are traditional and most used with lobster rolls, you can use any buns you like really. Just be sure to butter whatever buns you're using and toast them!

What's the Best Lobster for Lobster Rolls?

While there are many different types of lobster available, the best type for a lobster roll is freshly cooked Atlantic Canadian lobster. The sweet and succulent flavor of this variety makes it perfect for adding to a lobster roll.

The best parts of the lobster to use are the tail meat, claw meat and knuckle meat.

You can use either fresh lobster or frozen lobster that's been thawed. Pre cooked lobster is great for saving time, and you may even be able to find the frozen meat without lobster shells in the grocery store to save even more time!

How much lobster meat in a lobster roll?

Wondering how much lobster meat you should use in a delicious Lobster Roll? The answer is simple: as much as you like!

The beauty of Lobster Rolls is that they are totally customizable. You can make them with just a few bits of lobster, or pile it high with large chunks for a hearty meal.

Rather than buying whole lobsters, you can also buy frozen, cooked lobster tails and claws that can easily be thawed and added to the roll to beef up your roll easily.

Variations

The traditional lobster roll recipe is pretty simple, but if you'd like to change things up a bit, you could try adding a little hot sauce to the mayonnaise mixture if you like.

In the future, I'll post more variations here as I test things out!

Can I make Lobster Rolls ahead of time?

You can make the filling for lobster rolls ahead of time, but don't assemble the filling with the bun until it is ready to be served.

How to Store Leftovers
How long are Lobster Rolls good for?

To ensure your leftovers taste fresh and delicious, the lobster roll filling should be stored in the refrigerator in an air tight container. It should last up to three days if kept cold.

Lobster rolls should be assembled right before serving for best freshness, so please store the lobster roll filling in a container (separate from the buns) in the fridge if you're not serving them right away.

Can I freeze Lobster Rolls?

While technically, you can freeze lobster rolls, I wouldn't recommend freezing them assembled in their buns as it will affect the texture. If you plan on freezing them, it's best to freeze the prepared filling in a container, then assemble the rolls in buns before serving.

What to Serve with Lobster Rolls

• Freshly cooked potato wedges or French fries.
• Potato chips
• Dill pickles
• Buttery corn on the cob
• Steamed mussels or clams with a side of drawn butter for dipping
• Clam Chowder
• Coleslaw
• Mac and Cheese
• A fresh garden salad filled with crisp lettuce and crunchy veggies like cucumbers and tomatoes.

Print